III. >> M
ethodological Approaches to Human Rights Indicators
>> Sources and data-generating mechanisms
Box 15
Importance of administrative data in human rights assessments
A quantitative approach to assessing human rights in general and to monitoring the implementation of
a State’s human rights obligations in particular inevitably has to be informed by the use of meaningful,
standardized and cost-effective administrative data. There are several reasons why it is necessary to seek
administrative data on the State’s developmental and governance initiatives that can be related to the
promotion and protection of human rights.
Firstly
, administrative data are generated at the interface between an agency and the public or the ben
eficiaries of its actions. In other words, they reflect the efficacy of a State or its agency’s administrative
action in fulfilling obligations flowing from its developmental and governance objectives or its human
rights obligations. Such information is critical for holding States accountable.
Secondly
, administrative data meet the information requirement for policy and programme formulation
and show the progress in their implementation.
Thirdly, since the State is the primary human rights duty bearer and the assessment focuses on its action
or inaction, a data set that is generated by its own machinery is likely to be more acceptable to it than
information from non-governmental and other sources.
As administrative data are collected by various ministries and public agencies at grass-roots level, the third
consideration entails that the generation of administrative data should be based on rigorous guidelines and
standardized methodology for recording and compiling the relevant information. While these guidelines
could come from national statistical agencies and specialized international organizations, there is invariably
a need for a periodic independent review to establish the credibility of administrative data sets.
Statistical surveys
Statistical surveys are used to collect direct quantitative and qualitative information on population
subsets. In contrast to a census (see below), where
all members of the population have to be surveyed,
a statistical or sample survey collects data from a
fraction of the population under study, with the
objective of drawing inferences on the entire
population. In this respect, sample surveys are
cost-effective means of collecting information in
situations where complete enumeration is impracticable or data from administrative sources are not
available. Many indicators for the Millennium
Development Goals (MDGs) are compiled using
statistical survey data owing to the lack of accurate
administrative records. They constitute an important
data-generating mechanism for use in human rights
assessments for both public agencies (in generating
and validating administrative data) and non-
Human Rights Indicators
59
Hedef paragraf seç3
Bir paragrafa bağla
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
İçindekiler tablosuna ekle